Once and Again

Note: I decided on a whim yesterday I needed to write this before the next chapter comes out because in my ongoing love triangle series of sorts, Gabi should be choosing one of them in the next installment. I figure I’ll be losing half my readers if you are only Logan or Colt stans at that point, and felt the need to deliver some smut for both before that happens. One of these may be real, but the other most likely is not, so I’ve left that vague here as to which one.

As she stood on the dance floor with her head against his chest, swaying to the beat of a slow song, she could hardly believe it wasn’t just a dream. He came back to take her to prom and the night was more perfect than she could have ever imagined. Gabi felt whole again for the first time since he’d left. He bent down to kiss her sweetly on the lips, and she held his head there to whisper in his ear. “I want you tonight. I’m ready.”

~~~~~

Gabi took of her her heels, wondering what came next. Should she undress herself? Should she let him do it? She looked over to Logan, already sitting back against the headboard with his Jacket, vest, and bow-tie off, the first couple buttons of his shirt undone. With a shaky hand she reached around her back to start unzipping her dress.

“Come over here.” Logan chuckled softy, patting the spot on the bed next to him, and she climbed in. “We don’t have to rush.” He cupped her cheek in his hand and kissed her passionately yet unhurriedly. Gabi deepened the kiss and lifted her hands to the buttons on Logan’s shirt, but he grabbed her wrists, looking her intently and earnestly in the eyes. “I promise I’m not trying to talk you out of this because I’ve wanted this for so long, but I just want to make sure. Is this still what you want?”

She’s been ready for this for months, at least that’s what she thought. But now she’s glad they waited. Now that everything’s out in the open, and she’s certain it’s Logan she wants this timing is right. “Yes, Logan, I’ve never been more sure.”

A wide smile spread across his lips. “Exactly what I needed to hear.“ He kissed her again, this time with more intensity as he guided her down on the bed. He unzipped the back of her dress with one hand as he wove the fingers of his other through her hair. His mouth traveled down her neck to her shoulder and lower, kissing each newly exposed area and sending shivers across her skin. He looked up at her for reassurance, Gabi giving a slight nod before Logan proceeded to pull the fabric down over her breasts completely. Gabi sucked in a breath, feeling exposed and vulnerable for a moment until he took one nipple in his mouth, swirling his tongue around while massaging the other breast with his hand, and she felt a warm tingle run all the way down to her core. He got up on his knees and she shifted her hips as he shimmied her dress the rest of the way off. His gaze swept over her nearly naked body, but the way he looked at her made her feel wanted and loved. “You are amazing, Gabi.”

“So are you saying you’ve never caught a glimpse of me like this?” She teased to get a bit of the attention off of her.

“Oh, uh, possibly a little peak here and there, but it seemed like maybe you wanted me to?” She wasn’t quite sure, but she thought she may have witnessed him blush in front of her for the first time.

Gabi smirked. “Maybe I did, or maybe I was just terrible at remembering that you were in the room or to close the bathroom door.”

“Heh. I guess I’ll never know.” Logan chuckled and swooped his head back down, lavishing kisses lower and lower on her abdomen until he reached the lacy waistband of her pink thong. He hooked two fingers inside and pulled it off in one smooth motion, Gabi feeling how soaking wet it was as it slipped over her toes. Logan discarded his shirts before gliding his hands up her legs, stopping just short of the apex of her thighs, her muscles tensing in anticipation. “You still good?”

She nodded and Logan swiped a finger through her folds, then rolled it over and around her clit. “Oh!” Gabi cried out uncontrollably and much louder than she would have liked.

“Too much?” Logan asked, not waiting for an answer. “I have a better idea.” He dipped his head between her legs, his hot breath lingering on her sensitive skin before his tongue traced the same path where his finger had been. “Mmm,” he moaned as he tasted her, the vibrations tickling her sensitive nub, and she bucked her hips against his mouth in response. The feeling was better than anything she could describe and as licking, sucking, flicking motions quickened, she could feel herself being pushed closer to the edge. She fisted the sheets in her hands and closed her eyes as her body gave way to intense waves of pleasure radiating outward from her core, a whimper escaping her lips.

“Wow.” Gabi muttered through panted breaths as she came down from her high.

Logan laughed. “Did I tire you out already? We can just go to sleep if you want.”

“Get up here.” Gabi commanded and Logan quickly complied, pressing his lips against hers. She swiped her tongue over his lips, still tasting herself on him. She unbuckled his pants, and Logan worked with her swiftly pulling them off and then she knelt on the bed to take off his boxer briefs. She took in the sight of his hard cock as it sprung free, thinking of all the times she felt it through his clothes and wanted to take things further, and now they were here.

Gabi was frozen there, wondering what to do next, when Logan noticed her indecision and pulled her up next to him, sweeping a strand of hair out of her eyes. ”Are you ready?” She picked up the condom off the nightstand in response and handed it to him, Logan deftly opening the packing and rolling it onto his erection. He straddled her hips and carefully sunk down, guiding his tip into her entrance until he felt a bit of resistance. “You’ll let me know if it hurts, right?”

“Yes. Keep going,” Gabi urged. She felt a bit of pressure that was slightly uncomfortable but not painful until he slid all the way in and her walls stretched to accommodate him.

“Oh my God Gabi.” Logan pressed his full weight against her and nuzzled against her neck. “You are so incredible.” She grabbed his ass and rolled her hips, letting him know she was ready for more and he responded, gradually increasing the pace of his movements in time with hers. He propped himself up just enough to slip a hand between them, tracing circles over her clit, and almost out of nowhere, another orgasm overtook her, Gabi crying out his name as her walls rhythmically pulsed around him. She could tell he was already close and this was the final push he needed. He thrust into her hard a few more times and held her tightly as he found his release inside her.

Logan rolled them onto their sides and kept Gabi wrapped securely in his arms like he never wanted to let her go. “I love you Gabi, and I promise to never leave you again.”

~~~~~

Colt closed the door and pushed Gabi up against it, his tongue finding it’s way in her mouth, kissing her hard, shrugging off his jacket and untying his tie at the same time. “I want you so bad Gabi, but one last time, I want to be sure. This is what you want? I’m who you want?”

“Yes, Colt, I’m positive. Just keep kissing me.” Gabi pleaded. She’d been looking forward to getting Colt alone all night.

Colt licked his lips and pinned Gabi’s arm above her head, kissing her fiercely. He gathered both of her wrists in one hand and dropped the other down, bunching up the skirt of her dress as he slid his fingers up her inner thigh. His mouth descended on her neck, kissing, nibbling, and sucking along the way, sending shivers down her spine. She whimpered as brushed his finger over the top of her lace thong. “Fuck, Gabi, I can feel how wet you are already.” He pushed the fabric, slipping two fingers past her entrance and a guttural sound escaped Gabi’s lips at the sensation of fullness. “You good?” Gabi nodded emphatically and Colt crushed his lips to hers again as he worked his fingers inside her. Suddenly Colt pulled out and dropped to his knees. “I need to taste you, Gabi.” He ducked his head under her dress and pulled her thong off. He held her skirt at her hips, keeping her pushed back against the door as his tongue swirled through her folds and flicked her clit.

“Colt, that feels amazing,” she breathed. He positioned his lips over her most sensitive place and sucked with just the right amount of pressure, an indescribable feeling of pleasure swelling outward from her core.

Getting closer, she moaned louder, causing Colt to pull back. “Not yet. We aren’t even naked.”

“So strip!” Gabi giggled and pulled him to his feet.

Colt shook his head. “Ladies first.” She rolled her eyes but obeyed, unzipping her dress and letting it fall to the floor. She suddenly felt shy, standing there naked with him watching her, but the smile on his face put her at ease. “You’re so fucking hot, Gabi.”

He moved in close to kiss her, but she pushed him back. “Nope. You need to take your clothes off now.” He teased her, slowly undoing the top two buttons, so she got impatient and pulled his shirt apart, buttons popping off left and right.

“Whoa, Gabi.” Colt grabbed her hands and chuckled. “A little eager, aren’t we? Alright, alright.” He promptly removed the rest of his clothing and did a little spin. “Does it live up to your expectations?” Gabi just bit her lip and nodded as she stared in awe. She’d seen him down to just his boxer briefs before, but it just wasn’t the same. “Come here.” Colt tugged her by the waist and walked backwards, bringing her down on the bed with him. He kissed her slowly, deeply, caressing her face in his hands. “I’m ready whenever you are.” Gabi moved up further on the bed and Colt followed. She was in such a rush to get here, and its not that she was having second thoughts, but this was a big deal to Gabi, and her nerves started to catch up to her. “We can take it slow,” Colt added, seeming to sense her hesitation.

“I’m good,” Gabi assured him. “I just needed a second.”

“Okay, but I’m going to let you control the pace here.” He handed her a condom  and rested his head back on the pillows. Gabi fumbled to open the package, but she’d practiced this in sex ed before. She at least knew the right way to put it on. She grabbed his hard length in her hand and rolled the condom down. She looked up to him, thinking she knew what he was envisioning, and he gave her a nod of encouragement. She straddled his hips, centering herself over him and slowly lowering herself down. Colt took his hand to guide the head of his cock into her slit. It felt really tight, but she was wet enough get the first couple inches in without too much pain. After that, she easily took him in the rest of the way, and she moaned as he hit the sweet spot inside her. “You’re so good for me Gabi, you know that, right?”

She answered him with a kiss and rolled her hips, finding a steady rhythm. He clit rubbing against him as he moved with her, she felt her climax quickly approaching. She ground against him harder and faster and bit down on his shoulder to muffle a scream as she came apart seeing stars.

Colt rolled himself on top of her in one smooth motion. “Is this okay?” Gabi nodded again in approval and Colt thrust into her faster and faster. She raked her nails across his back, digging in when he pushed into her deep. “Fuck, yes, Gabi!” he cried out as he came, his cock still throbbing inside her as he collapsed on her chest.

They snuggled up together after cleaning up and Colt pressed a kiss to her forehead. “I’m sorry for being such a selfish asshole. I’m honestly not sure why you took me back, but I’m going to make sure you never regret it.”

~~~~~

One was real, and one was just a dream. Both were perfect, but only one was meant to be.